Guild icon
Teeworlds
IRC / bridge
One-way IRC channel bridge. If you want to be able to send messages to IRC, contact @Dune or @heinrich5991. https://www.teeworlds.com/?page=docs&wiki=rules/irc_rules
Between 2020-02-15 00:00:00Z and 2020-02-16 00:00:00Z
Avatar
Can maps contain extra data that can be retrieved by the server?
14:17
arbitrary data
14:21
like some string contained in the map.
Avatar
yes, maps have envelopes where you can store author and comments
14:41
technically you can store anything in a map
Avatar
cookie authentication
14:47
or jwt token
14:49
not authentication, but more of authorization
Avatar
@jxsl13 the client does not send anything about the map back to the server, except for whether it needs to download it
18:01
you cannot set a string or so that the client will play back to you
Avatar
so, the only data that's retrievable is tue existance of a map, that can be used to encode data. https://github.com/jxsl13/zcatch/issues/61
18:11
binary encoding based on fake maps.
Avatar
if you're tracking users, you need to think about the gdpr
Avatar
@heinrich5991 are honeypots servers considered a bannable offense?
Avatar
probably yes
19:42
what kind of honeypots?
Avatar
servers with exact same config
Avatar
thats what i wanted to ask
Avatar
no provable malice though
Avatar
do you know which one was there earlier?
Avatar
so account sniffing and s tuff
Avatar
it's @Trafalgar Law's server and it says Trafalgar Law's server in the name
Avatar
gametype?
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 19:43:47Z
All the same
Avatar
ah somebody is phising players
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 19:44:20Z
Yesterday crashed my Multimap_Less Server and all thought it was my Server but they joined the fake srv (edited)
Avatar
108.191.164.78:8302 is the fake server
19:45
the ping is very bad and the IP is different
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 19:45:52Z
They actually use the same port as my server
Avatar
maybe add a rule to the masterservers, that you can't register when a server with the same name exist already?
Avatar
nah you can go around this easily
Avatar
with another masterserver
19:46
yes
Avatar
don't need a rule for that anyway, no malice should be obvious
Avatar
the master server doesn't know about the servers' names currenty
19:47
currently*
Avatar
ChillerDragon 2020-02-15 19:47:11Z
Rip unnamed server
Avatar
make it an exception, like nameless tee
Avatar
that's ugly imo ^^
Avatar
ChillerDragon 2020-02-15 19:48:05Z
Add verified servers 🙂
Avatar
or just ban honeypots
Avatar
banned
Avatar
should go away in the next hours
Avatar
Add CA system :p
Avatar
ChillerDragon 2020-02-15 19:49:00Z
😄
Avatar
so i can't annoy anyone with MITM attacks :p
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 19:49:04Z
Thanks @heinrich5991
Avatar
well, teeworlds would need a https client for this, the game itself should obv. still run on tcp and udp directly
Avatar
cas work without https
Avatar
I woudn't know how to implement it <.<
Avatar
lol, that is not really clever to ban server for having he same name. as you have no proof if someone asks for you to ban the incorrect server while hosting their own server with the same name.
Avatar
the server had the person's name in its name
19:58
[8:42 PM] heinrich5991: do you know which one was there earlier?
Avatar
names are not bound to accounts and nobody's property
Avatar
yes
19:59
yet if you and someone else were to host a jxsl13's server, I know which to ban
19:59
"magic, right?"
Avatar
I would not care.
Avatar
great
Avatar
as I do not call my server's that
Avatar
so the case is closed :)
Avatar
what about people faking servers that do not contain anyone's nicks?
19:59
what about generic server names
Avatar
what are you concerned about, @jxsl13 ?
Avatar
I'm concerned about you people introducing arbitrary rules.
20:00
however you please
Avatar
faking servers does have a security impact
20:01
sniffing server logins was done before, and we have already banned servers for that 5 years ago
Avatar
same servers have an account system so you could phish accounts by faking servers
Avatar
can you proof that the server sniffs login credentials?
Avatar
no
Avatar
very doubtful we'll ever have grey cases in those
Avatar
it's obviously visible that that server is different when one looks at the ping
Avatar
I don't understand what you are trying to achieve here, @jxsl13
Avatar
not everyone is a network expert like us
Avatar
I want that server unbanned, as it's been banned on asumptions
20:02
and not on any facts
Avatar
if it's your server, present your case
20:03
if not, ask the server owner to do it please
Avatar
Law asked for it and his name was in the server name
Avatar
especially as there is not proof in any form and nobody has any right to claim any nicknames, what's the basic system of teeworlds
20:03
it's a flaw in the system, not in the people hosting servers.
20:04
it's not my server.
20:04
thus you try to avoid the issue, what if I hosted the same server.
20:04
I'd simply bring this forth, just to bring up this issue.
Avatar
what if I hosted the same server.
20:04
if it's your server, present your case
Avatar
if I fake your zCatch server @jxsl13 would you care?
Avatar
let me startup a clone
20:05
no, as you don't have my ranking data
20:05
so nobody would care
Avatar
but I will receive your admin probably from tweef
Avatar
and what would you do?
Avatar
login in your server
Avatar
I have logs and can simply change the login
20:05
wow
20:05
tell m ypeople to favourite their server, wher ethey ar emods and that would get you nothing
20:06
arbitrary ban on assumptions
20:06
that's what this is
Avatar
banning random people, changing some values maybe gravity, maybe you aren't online on this day?
Avatar
I'd get informed
20:07
as I am available via discord
Avatar
damage is already done at this point
Avatar
happens
20:07
same as when a mod tells their password to someone
Avatar
I don't know if you have any database commands
20:07
like deleting some players stats
Avatar
for sure I don't
20:07
having database commands would be dumb
Avatar
no backups, no pity
Avatar
do you get a notification if somebody unknown logs into admin?
Avatar
maybe i don't do much, except being unbannable
Avatar
I don't see your point, it's damage that's avoidable with a little bit of intelligence
20:09
favoriting your servers
Avatar
you never want random people being able to do anything with your stuff unerpermited
20:09
thats rule #1 on the internet
Avatar
getting ones server banned falls under that?
20:10
randomly
Avatar
maybe it's not much damage in your case, but what about other servers?
20:10
and faking a server is a clear phishing case
Avatar
I'd say it's a case that tries to get players from those server's, not necessarily their data
20:11
there have been ton os these cases in 0.6
20:11
tons of
20:11
and nobody cared
20:12
and getting players is not an offense, is it?
20:12
banning servers on assumtions, that's all this is.
20:12
assumptions*
Avatar
do you think that the banned server was not the copy?
Avatar
no, as it's missing the player data
20:14
which is obviously visible by times, when the player plays there
Avatar
then everything seems to be fine
20:15
we made the right judgement according to you, as to which server was the copy
Avatar
no, it wa snot a copy?
Avatar
oh. I ment which server had the server name later
20:16
*meant
Avatar
since when is having the same name an offense?
Avatar
I was trying to establish the other thing first
Avatar
I understand the problem, but this is introducing arbitrary judgement on solely assumptions
20:18
can the masterserver proof which server was there first?
20:18
as anyone could tell you which server was first
20:19
assumptions
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 20:19:07Z
You should also know that my server was first
Avatar
I know that it was there first, it's not exactly about your server, it's a case that might change the judgement in further cases like these heavily
20:20
as judgement is done based on assumptions here, not on exact proof
20:20
if it's an unknown server
20:20
any somone said that somone else is faking their server
20:20
who would you trust
Avatar
there's a third option there: don't ban any of these if you don't know
Avatar
I would say this is always the option, as currently this is based on assumptions that it's a phishing server
20:21
by just having the same name
Avatar
you just said that we have a consensus that this was the fake
Avatar
is having the same name already considered being fake?
Avatar
yes
Avatar
since when?
Avatar
if it's such a unique name
20:22
I don't know, we had such a case before
20:22
search the IRC channel logs
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 20:23:09Z
It happend already with L# Servers
Avatar
what is considered unique
Avatar
people's judgement
Avatar
mushy definition
20:24
mushy judgement in my opinion.
20:24
as no proof
20:24
well, it's fake cuz "unique" same name
20:25
is tw.com down?
Avatar
no
Avatar
oh, I'm dumb, teworlds
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 20:26:09Z
😂
20:27
should be updated then
20:29
I wonder how the case will be handled if 3 people tell you that one server is the fake and another 5 people tell you the other server is fake, while pressuring you annoyingly. This will seemingly be fun to watch.
20:29
And I will happily say I told you 😄
20:29
but currently the game doesn't have enough players to have such problems, yet.
Avatar
Great, let's just disagree here then 🙂
20:30
I'm fine with that.
20:30
just wanted to present my point.
Avatar
it would be better received without condescension
Avatar
well, I find that judgement arbitrary and baseless.
Avatar
still, no condescension please
Avatar
same name -> ban
Avatar
we presented the reasoning
Avatar
there is no unban function and this server is banned forever
Avatar
there is an unban function. contact the admins
Avatar
no, you lying
Avatar
ok
Avatar
that's how servers have always been unbanned, @Assa
Avatar
assa is trolling
20:34
maybe
Avatar
*probably
Avatar
*assably
Avatar
[quakenet] rand BOT 2020-02-15 20:44:19Z
poor guy that wanted genuinely to host a server that appeared to have the exact same name and gametype
Avatar
unnames server - dm
20:45
unnamed server - dm
20:49
I think the problem is more of how do you proof who was there first if the server is not that well known. Maybe someone had the same name, as they call themselves the same. If teeworlds for example had 3million players and 60000 players. and you had this exact same problem.
20:50
how would the judgement be.
Avatar
could probably not be done manually then
Avatar
what is unique if someoe else has the same ingame nick, as it's a character from One Piece a widely known anime.
20:51
uniqueness is not objective
20:52
anyway, case closed.
Avatar
uniqueness can be measured if you want
20:52
statistics is a thing
20:52
but I don't want to do that, that sounds more annoying than it is worth
20:53
e.g. ddnet servers do some sort of closeness computation on nicks
20:53
"objective"
Avatar
googling a nickname is enough of a uniqueness test
20:54
test my nick
20:54
x)
20:55
and google Trafalgar Law 😄
Avatar
Trafalgar Law 2020-02-15 20:56:15Z
Well Law's could be stand too for the "Law"
20:56
😉
20:56
But true the name is from Trafalgar Law
Avatar
if you google my real name, you won't find me
22:37
if you google Essigautomat however, you find all my gaming accounts, old profile pictures and stuff
Avatar
[quakenet] minus BOT 2020-02-15 22:41:49Z
Essiggurkenautomat sounds like a good name for a band
Avatar
[quakenet] Dune BOT 2020-02-15 22:49:59Z
what does it mean? :
22:50
:)
Avatar
[quakenet] heinrich5991 BOT 2020-02-15 22:50:36Z
vending machine for pickles
22:56
was that disappointing? ^^
Avatar
vinegar vending machine
Avatar
missing cucumbers
Exported 224 message(s)