Use the doors on the switch layers instead if you want them to open and close. Put them on any unused number (you can find them in the top left). Put the doors and the switches on the same number so they interact with each other.
PopCorn181
Use the doors on the switch layers instead if you want them to open and close. Put them on any unused number (you can find them in the top left). Put the doors and the switches on the same number so they interact with each other.
@ᶰ°Konͧsti@murpi
Hey.
I clearly remember the situation that happened with these two maps. Of course, the El Futuro version was created first. That "Pablik" was hosted on the "KonaTbI4" server for only a few days, after which El Futuro himself registered on Trutee forum and wrote a big angry post, accusing the Russian mapmakers of plagiarism. Of course everyone on the forum supported the original author and the map was removed from the servers. At that time "HDP Obstaculos" had already existed for more than half-year, I think.
P. S.: I'm not that "Jamby" who is listed in the authors of the "Pablik" map. I just have the same nickname on discord/steam rn.
In fact, the history of the origin of this map is still a mystery to me. 3 authors for just redesigning the map. Jamby himself at that time was already a relatively well-known mapper of DDrace/fng maps. I communicated with him quite well while playing on the "KonaTbI4", and even took part in the test of his maps (not this one). But he still didn't admit how he was involved in this story. А couple of years ago I got caught with him on the server, playing just this map "HDP Obstaculos". I joked that he was the real author and again tried to find out how they made this copy of the map, but he never talked about this topic.
@ᶰ°Konͧsti@murpi
Hey.
I clearly remember the situation that happened with these two maps. Of course, the El Futuro version was created first. That "Pablik" was hosted on the "KonaTbI4" server for only a few days, after which El Futuro himself registered on Trutee forum and wrote a big angry post, accusing the Russian mapmakers of plagiarism. Of course everyone on the forum supported the original author and the map was removed from the servers. At that time "HDP Obstaculos" had already existed for more than half-year, I think.
P. S.: I'm not that "Jamby" who is listed in the authors of the "Pablik" map. I just have the same nickname on discord/steam rn.
In fact, the history of the origin of this map is still a mystery to me. 3 authors for just redesigning the map. Jamby himself at that time was already a relatively well-known mapper of DDrace/fng maps. I communicated with him quite well while playing on the "KonaTbI4", and even took part in the test of his maps (not this one). But he still didn't admit how he was involved in this story. А couple of years ago I got caught with him on the server, playing just this map "HDP Obstaculos". I joked that he was the real author and again tried to find out how they made this copy of the map, but he never talked about this topic.
As I said, at the time of creation "Pablik", Obstaculos already existed for more than six months and was also hosted on KonaTbI4's servers. There wasn't test team at the time to discover such a case
No information currently available extends to the date when Pablik 1 was first found. So unless someone finds actual facts with source, any other claims would merely be regarded as unverified rumors. :/
The earliest mention of the HDP_Obstaculos that I was able to find is May 12, 2012 in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0UeF7U_O-4&t=116s
It's still not 2011, but it's closer to that than the version from Heinrich's archive (April 12, 2013).
And as @ᶰ°Konͧsti already pointed out, it is very suspicious that the "Pablik" shows the name "ELFUTURO", and all the mapres are titled as "ELFUTURO"
I wrote about it to HeroiAmarelo on teeworlds.com forum since he is present in this video and he held a tournament on this map in 2012 (there is a thread on teeworlds forum). Maybe he will be able to tell something. I hope he still visits that forum
Here's a video of el futuro playing in the HDP clan leader's video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HgiUsLvjZQ suggesting that he's a member of HDP, or at least plays with them
Here's a video of el futuro playing in the HDP clan leader's video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HgiUsLvjZQ suggesting that he's a member of HDP, or at least plays with them
This video is July 11th, 2011... The fact that the "Pablik" version has his name in it should be enough proof to keep it as HDP imo, nothing indicates el futuro having anything to do with the russian community, only HDP
@ᶰ°Konͧsti@murpi
Hey.
I clearly remember the situation that happened with these two maps. Of course, the El Futuro version was created first. That "Pablik" was hosted on the "KonaTbI4" server for only a few days, after which El Futuro himself registered on Trutee forum and wrote a big angry post, accusing the Russian mapmakers of plagiarism. Of course everyone on the forum supported the original author and the map was removed from the servers. At that time "HDP Obstaculos" had already existed for more than half-year, I think.
P. S.: I'm not that "Jamby" who is listed in the authors of the "Pablik" map. I just have the same nickname on discord/steam rn.
In fact, the history of the origin of this map is still a mystery to me. 3 authors for just redesigning the map. Jamby himself at that time was already a relatively well-known mapper of DDrace/fng maps. I communicated with him quite well while playing on the "KonaTbI4", and even took part in the test of his maps (not this one). But he still didn't admit how he was involved in this story. А couple of years ago I got caught with him on the server, playing just this map "HDP Obstaculos". I joked that he was the real author and again tried to find out how they made this copy of the map, but he never talked about this topic.
This video is July 11th, 2011... The fact that the "Pablik" version has his name in it should be enough proof to keep it as HDP imo, nothing indicates el futuro having anything to do with the russian community, only HDP
As I remember, El Futuro attached a screenshot with his nickname and also pointed it out on the Trutee.ru forum.
Unfortunately, I don’t know if there is at least one other witness who remembers this situation and continues to play Teeworlds
Hein's map list doesn't even have any entries for HDP_Obstaculos in 2012, even though there are forum posts indicating someone hosting it in 2012. @heinrich5991 What are your thoughts on this? Why wouldn't it be recorded on your list?
is there a way how to get creation date form map file?
Skeith
Hein's map list doesn't even have any entries for HDP_Obstaculos in 2012, even though there are forum posts indicating someone hosting it in 2012. @heinrich5991 What are your thoughts on this? Why wouldn't it be recorded on your list?
Lots of people in 2010-2012 era wanted to have their own servers but didn't rly knew how to make maps.
It was a very common practice to make your own server. Take someones map. Add name of your "clan" on the map and release it on your server. Sometimes they did make few tiny changes in the maps.
Everyone in that era knew HDP maps only few knew Pablik.
heinrich database is not by any means a source to gather info about dates of map releases. Lots of maps in that database are some leaked alpha/beta versions.
el futuro's name is on the 2011 "pablik" version, the video I posted above has el futuro playing with HDP players, that video predates the pablik release date in hein's list, if you're going entirely off of that (you were) then you can safely rename it back
yeah as i also said. Russian community is also pretty well known for stealing maps, EpicFail for example published the Freedoom series as Decline series
Skeith
el futuro's name is on the 2011 "pablik" version, the video I posted above has el futuro playing with HDP players, that video predates the pablik release date in hein's list, if you're going entirely off of that (you were) then you can safely rename it back
The fact that his name is there, suggests he made the original version, it's in the same location as the non pablik version, it suggests they stole the map
10:04
Why would they randomly put spanish words on their map, they're russian
10:04
The same words as the name of a well known mapper at the time (el futuro)(edited)
10:05
A well known mapper that has ties with HDP clan members
Skeith
The fact that his name is there, suggests he made the original version, it's in the same location as the non pablik version, it suggests they stole the map
Its you who imply something that is not true.
@heinrich5991 there was no insult in what I wrote stop implying that I have insulted anyone.
Name of that map is not Pablik 1 and it should be changed.
"don't rely on dates in the map archive
they don't show when maps first appeared, they might at most show when I added them
I haven't consistently added new maps over the year"
we have on one side as proof date in archive whose creator saying they might be wrong
and other side
Jamby's witness
El Futuro's spanish (obstaculous = obstacles in spanish)
video connecting him with HDP clan dating before archive Pablik date
and I strongly feel when I played this map with /r /save and /load on ddrace+ in 2011 it was called HDP_Obstaculous and not Pablik
Skeith
I don't think a single person recognizes that map as Pablik 1, it was one of the most played maps back in the day
@murpi Okay, well, I don't think I can clarify much. As it was from my side - tututu or Jamby (I don't have their contacts left and I don't remember the details, and skype deleted all the history) asked me to help with the map, they wanted to make a Pablik map, but with new obstacles, as the first version was already finished many times and they wanted something new. Who first renamed HDP_Obstaculous to Pablik I don't know, I didn't participate in it, I only added obstacles to the map. I do not think that the map is unique, but it was not made with the purpose of plagiarism.
10:51
Also, I didn't know the third version existed until today.
Skeith
I'd be very shocked if he said Pablik was the original
Because the map was named HDP_Obstaculos when everyone was playing it, it wasn't blue like in the "Pablik" version, and the pablik version added nothing new to it, it simply removed elfuturo's credits but missed one
Faulty
@murpi Okay, well, I don't think I can clarify much. As it was from my side - tututu or Jamby (I don't have their contacts left and I don't remember the details, and skype deleted all the history) asked me to help with the map, they wanted to make a Pablik map, but with new obstacles, as the first version was already finished many times and they wanted something new. Who first renamed HDP_Obstaculous to Pablik I don't know, I didn't participate in it, I only added obstacles to the map. I do not think that the map is unique, but it was not made with the purpose of plagiarism.
Our discussion has primarily centered around Pablik 1 exclusively. Your last sentence does seem to suggest that HDP_Obstaculous is the original; could you provide further clarification on this point?
Skeith
Because the map was named HDP_Obstaculos when everyone was playing it, it wasn't blue like in the "Pablik" version, and the pablik version added nothing new to it, it simply removed elfuturo's credits but missed one
I gather there are some people who are absolutely sure of that. I don't know what it was really like, I wasn't familiar with El Futuro. Maybe someone still has his contacts, as it would be easier to ask him of course....
Just to make it clear. I don't know the story behind HDP map and Pablik 1. I also don't know and don't have any source to show which one was first.
I believe that HDP was the first one (this is only my believe). Theres also a fact that El Futuro made lots of great maps before that one. It would be rly strange for him taking someons map and add his name to it (it is possible yet very doubtful).
I am howerver one hundred percent sure that what we see on ddnet website is not a map that should be named Pablik 1
Its real name starts as HDP_O........
I see from whole conversation that everyone agree that "Pablik 1" version and "HDP_O...." version are diffrent versions of one map so why names were swapped ?
I'm totally fine with renaming it back, if that's what people want btw. Everything I've said here is solely just an opinion of mine and not some kind of decision to keep it renamed.
A proposal was made to rename HDP_Obstaculos to Pablik 1 since the earliest documented discovery of Pablik 1 predates HDP_Obstaculos, suggesting the map could potentially been stolen.
yeah I understand that but still we all know that Pablik 1 is diffrent version. From my point of view the map should keep its name with the version of the map. Swapping names between versions just makes the stuff worse =/
If players want HDP version on ddnet keep HDP version and HDP name. If however players want Pablik 1 version then keep Pablik 1 version and Pablik 1 name.
rly odd xD
It’s history that’s been around for a long time and this shouldn’t be changed at random
11:17
Tsin
If players want HDP version on ddnet keep HDP version and HDP name. If however players want Pablik 1 version then keep Pablik 1 version and Pablik 1 name.
rly odd xD
this, ive also only known it as Obstaculos and i started in early 2012, never heard of Pablik. And its not the only map that was stolen by russian players. I have contact to Kon4at and could also ask him what he remembers
The guy also said they renamed the map, the credits at the start had the "HDP" clan tag, which is further proof the map was just outright stolen, in my opinion.
Skeith
I'd be very shocked if he said Pablik was the original
of course i read everything topic related. But just some map versions in heinrich index isnt factual data to rename it. There wasnt a big discussion like it is here now to investigate the origin of the map. The heinrich index never got access to all maps and servers back in the time, even though its a really helpfull tool.
What i want to point out is that there was way less arguments delivered to rename it in the first place then now claims that Obstaculos is the original map. So i dont really understand your hesitation to rename it back as what i see here looks like the russian players stole it and not the other way around. Which would fit other happenings of stolen maps by the same player group
yeah i see that but your way of going seems to be that we have to provide more factual data even though it seems pretty clear for renaming it back than you needed for changing it in the beginning
Crude explanation on how to compare two maps:
Use twmap-tools provided by Patiga's twmap library to convert the two maps into mapdir format and then simply use any diff tool to compare both directories.
Check your ddnet directory (where the client resides), you'll find an executable file named "map_diff.exe". To use it, you can simply drag and drop two maps onto this executable, and it should work it's magic.
12:21
But again, it only works for minor map changes I think.
hard to integrate tho, because the awesome library twmap by @Patiga is in rust, with python bindings tho, it would be easier to just make a external tool and load the map there
i guess u add 3 tile layers with the 3 colors green, red, yellow and do the diff git like, the question is whether the diff is just on game layer or other
Tsin
and I think that Ryozuki is just an attention seeker person =]
so to get to the topic
@Ravie please think about releasing this tool so that other mappers could work more efficient while working on group project
Ryozuki
i guess u add 3 tile layers with the 3 colors green, red, yellow and do the diff git like, the question is whether the diff is just on game layer or other
i guess a elaborate script would add layer groups, each layer group has the 3 tile layers for the diff, the group named for each special layer (game, front, tele)(edited)
I'm totally fine with renaming it back, if that's what people want btw. Everything I've said here is solely just an opinion of mine and not some kind of decision to keep it renamed.
The map is several years old, I honestly wouldn't be surprised if they don't care since they appear to not have been a part of the game for a long time.
I mean I do want the real map name to be used, but unless you can get a hold of several old-school players and make a private vote or a better option entirely I don't see any other way lol
13:29
Besides just finally finding 100% definitive proof
13:30
But it seems like more people are on the obstaculos side
They definitely could, and have all right to (assuming it really is their map, which I do agree on but not from experience), but it's been years, and they clearly haven't been a part of the community for years(edited)
I refer to them as council of elders. They have an extraordinary recollection of all events from a full decade ago. In their eyes, most of the time, any contrary information or differing opinions are considered inaccurate or misguided. Debates of this nature escalate into highly emotional exchanges pretty much always.
Broso56
Just make a community vote, it's a clear cut answer of what people want. If needed point to this conversation and they can gather their own opionion
I don't think we really need to do a poll on this, imo.
murpi
I refer to them as council of elders. They have an extraordinary recollection of all events from a full decade ago. In their eyes, most of the time, any contrary information or differing opinions are considered inaccurate or misguided. Debates of this nature escalate into highly emotional exchanges pretty much always.
When I said that I was just going off of you seeing what the community wants, but if you already have an answer or don't think it's important enough to do so sure
Welcome to Teeskins — the largest collection of community created Teeworlds Skins. Download, Upload and Share Skins, Mapres, Gameskins, Emoticons, Cursors, Particles, Entities, Fonts, Grids and useful tools.