This channel is for all Teeworlds/DDNet and related chat. Gameplay questions can be asked here as well rather than in #questions. Ingame screenshots and any other Teeworlds related media goes to #showroom.
Between 2022-07-05 00:00:00Z and 2022-07-06 00:00:00Z
I was thinking of making this as a compromise for old players that just hate everything new. Clientside freeze particles that behave like the old stars
why wouldnt you add an option for freeze bar alpha OUTSIDE freeze, lol
10:50
im so sad actually about this whole thing, even other people said they dont like all of this, why do you not listen to the community. its kinda egoistic to say nah we dont hear you lets just get it in like this for this version
10:50
:/
10:51
also whats so bad about having an option, for a thing which is very important to many players, and which is like visible 99% of the whole play time
10:51
instead we have options for stuff that is so unnecessary
10:53
and no, i dont want to create my own client which always sends client version < 16020 just to get the stars on ddnet server etc.
i want to update my client regularly
fokkonaut
im so sad actually about this whole thing, even other people said they dont like all of this, why do you not listen to the community. its kinda egoistic to say nah we dont hear you lets just get it in like this for this version
It's so sad to hear a handful of people think their opinion represents the entire community.
We try to not add more options because it becomes unmaintainable. A lot of the unnecessary options you mention are half a decade old and mostly broken, hence unmaintainable.
It's so sad to hear a handful of people think their opinion represents the entire community.
where did i say that? did you read disocrd + github? people actually agree to me. Sad from you
10:56
We try to not add more options because it becomes unmaintainable. A lot of the unnecessary options you mention are half a decade old and mostly broken, hence unmaintainable.
Then why dont remove them and add important options, like this one?!
fokkonaut
It's so sad to hear a handful of people think their opinion represents the entire community.
where did i say that? did you read disocrd + github? people actually agree to me. Sad from you
We try to not add more options because it becomes unmaintainable. A lot of the unnecessary options you mention are half a decade old and mostly broken, hence unmaintainable.
Then why dont remove them and add important options, like this one?!
I said you have to listen to the community, in terms of actually listening to the opinions of everyone. And not simply ignore them (especially in cases like this, with BIG changes)
10:58
We did votes in the past, and why not for this? or at least votes for an option
10:58
More than half of the community didnt know this will come
I'll make something for you, enough of this discussion. You can go celebrate with your friends about how you made big bad devs fold and rescued the players from the horrible unteeish change.
Freezebars are good and bad, it's definitely easier to understand for new players, and you can definitely time things better. But it definitely is a bit distracting. Remove the option for displaying freezebar in freeze, it's useless. Change it to opacity outside of freeze.
I like the hud but dont like freezebar and no weapon in freeze too
Learath2
I'll make something for you, enough of this discussion. You can go celebrate with your friends about how you made big bad devs fold and rescued the players from the horrible unteeish change.
@Learath2 show me how many people in this convo actually liked the freeze bar. I didnt mean to be toxic or anything, but you really just didnt want to see the truth
11:10
sorry
11:10
i can 100% understand that new players probably prefer this
11:10
100%
11:10
np
11:11
that doesnt mean its actually better
fokkonaut
@Learath2 show me how many people in this convo actually liked the freeze bar. I didnt mean to be toxic or anything, but you really just didnt want to see the truth
That will also suffer from the same thing. This discord is not representative of the playerbase as a whole, nor will people that are neutral or dont care about the community aspect will even vote
@Learath2 i think we can stop now, everything said. And thanks for making something
Learath2
That will also suffer from the same thing. This discord is not representative of the playerbase as a whole, nor will people that are neutral or dont care about the community aspect will even vote
The freeze bar and the hud are a good step into making the game cleaner. But, you could make a "retro" mode option so that people choosing it can play with the old design (leaving it as it is without adding further changes) and turning it off by default.(edited)
@Learath2 i mean, more like chinese players play very different games, and they probably enjoy the freeze bar more. thats just my guess, and thats okay, as i said, lets just keep both
@Learath2 why didnt you just stop when i asked for, and when i said its okay, and that i am thankful u do something (i even suggested i can do something)
11:29
but sure, keep trying to make me look like the toxic one
You are not going to get banned for crying about a feature like the 20 other people here. Every single one of you cry about every single change, no one got banned for it once
Yoooo, I only SERIOUSLY cried about the no message in chat change, that shit was not thought out at all, and would've seriously hindered newer players. I guess a did cry a little about freesebars, but I gave actual constructive feedback.
11:41
For powerups
Meekrioz
I like the freeze bar, there should be an option to use it or not but that's just me
Oh and if the past is any indicator for the future I'd be very surprised if the guy that got this feature in after almost 3 months of debates will come back for another PR(edited)
Tag him once more i think he hasnt seen ur message
Learath2
Oh and if the past is any indicator for the future I'd be very surprised if the guy that got this feature in after almost 3 months of debates will come back for another PR (edited)
It's impossible to poll for UI properly, people here will always complain about features that target new players, how are we supposed to have votes when a majority of this discord doesn't care about new player UX at all?
cyberFighter
i can send u the hud image with the transparent freeze bar tho
@Iza me neither, but thats the point. learath definitely knows that too, and he definitely tried to make me look bad, because he probably knows his own issues and is just not a man to say so, or even apologize(edited)
It was changed like 3 times because people didn't like some things. The inside freeze alpha thing was completely because we talked about it in discord #5420 was full of changes due to feedback
fokkonaut
@Iza read everything, or simply dont mix things up now. thanks
Your only objective argument has been that the freeze bar is attached to the tee. Why would essential information about the tee not be attached to the tee? How are the stars being part of the game world a beneficial thing? You say that as if it's a given something that is true no matter what
Freeze bars have better information though, the issue is you give up clarity for it. Just adding opacity options for outside of freeze solves this all, honestly.
I guess an alpha doesn't hurt maintainability, hopefully it'll quell the angers of some people. The old indicator thing I'm not sure about, I don't want to add it but old players just passionately want it, maybe I can write it and fokkonaut can promise to maintain it?
I guess an alpha doesn't hurt maintainability, hopefully it'll quell the angers of some people. The old indicator thing I'm not sure about, I don't want to add it but old players just passionately want it, maybe I can write it and fokkonaut can promise to maintain it?
I don't get it @fokkonaut you are really just being mean for no reason now. You said your opinion, I said I don't think it's as widely held as you think it is. I explained why I didn't think a vote is appropriate here due to selection bias. I even inquired about your only objective argument which you didn't even dignify with a response
Actually if guys want to attract more devs, you should either make a dev blog (like i do hehe), document stuff better, improve the wiki dev article. The first one having the most outreach.
The freeze bar is a community concern. Your opinion about the freeze bar is held by a few people, mostly older players that miss the stars. I haven't been saying anything different for the last hour
@Learath2 ok anyways, your behaviour wasnt nice. im out now. and you should work on that.
Learath2
The freeze bar is a community concern. Your opinion about the freeze bar is held by a few people, mostly older players that miss the stars. I haven't been saying anything different for the last hour
The freeze bar is a community concern. Your opinion about the freeze bar is held by a few people, mostly older players that miss the stars. I haven't been saying anything different for the last hour
Why do you think it clutters the space more than the stars? It takes up more space temporally but it takes less space on the screen as demonstrated a couple pictures above
Why do you think it clutters the space more than the stars? It takes up more space temporally but it takes less space on the screen as demonstrated a couple pictures above
we just had no bar before this i guess? The bar was introduced in 0.7 as a ninja bar dont? But you saw stars before, when taking damage, when shooting with a projectile against a wall, but you just had no solid bar and i think that is the problem(edited)
why is it so important to smooth the appearence like that? maybe its nice for the new new players i guess, but the more experienced a player gets, the more technical he wants the ui to be
i think this is the main point that make me miss stars, in normal 3* freeze my brain only use the 2* animation to time the unfreeze and the rest of info is useless. To have a bar whole time doing countdown is useless and distracting for me, of course that is better for new player but when u know how to timing the unfreeze the bar is useless and i dont like to fully hide the bar as a solution. Anyway is my first day using it, we all will get used to it probably and the solution @cyberFighter gave about transparence can work good.
with stars you can't time it perfect, even if you're the most experienced player
Lagar
i think this is the main point that make me miss stars, in normal 3* freeze my brain only use the 2* animation to time the unfreeze and the rest of info is useless. To have a bar whole time doing countdown is useless and distracting for me, of course that is better for new player but when u know how to timing the unfreeze the bar is useless and i dont like to fully hide the bar as a solution. Anyway is my first day using it, we all will get used to it probably and the solution @cyberFighter gave about transparence can work good.
The stars weren't tick accurate, they were I think maaybe second accurate, they didn't use to be but I remember some discussion around making them accurate
Iza
with stars you can't time it perfect, even if you're the most experienced player
yeah. i know ppl are like "uhhh make a game mode that uses more of them". whos gonna remember the other 2 stars out of smthlike uh.. 4 player fng?(edited)
correct me if im wrong, but timing others is rarely a thing, its usually done in combination with both or one being frozen and holding the key, since its buffered
Lagar
for vertically jump boost i think he mean, one tee hold jump freezed and u hit him just after he unfreeze for the boost
correct me if im wrong, but timing others is rarely a thing, its usually done in combination with both or one being frozen and holding the key, since its buffered
The new HUD changes feels very strange but its probably just me overthinking it
-I thought with less things on the screen the game would look and maybe feel better but with how jumps are displayed its a much bigger distraction since every 2seconds I see something flash in the corner in my eye,with the old HUD we couldn't see our jumps displayed but only a countdown with the shields to indicate when you unfreeze which isn't distracting since you aren't doing stuff while frozen 99% of the time
-The snowflakes while in freeze is much more distracting since they are persistent and spawn way too frequently than with the stars flashing once and not follow you the whole time
-When you shoot weapons while in freeze something feels "off" but im not sure what it is
-When playing with dummy and using deepfly bind I have the same problem as with the jump indicator,the dummy icon flashing whole time when it hammers so it becomes distracting imo
-The freezebar isn't a bad change but having something solid staying under the person following them the whole time is also distracting,maybe if it was more transparent it would look better?
can we not just change the old stars to snowflakes and have them toggleable
also why add snowflakes instead of just turning the (cursed) swordless ninja skin into a frozen blueish variant
Every single ui change is a good change for new players but the update lacks options for older players that liked the old ui more to toggle the old ui
15:47
I mean it's more intuitive to look at the hud for jumps instead of player feet or to look at the progress bar under frozen tees instead of how many stars are there around them
can we not just change the old stars to snowflakes and have them toggleable
also why add snowflakes instead of just turning the (cursed) swordless ninja skin into a frozen blueish variant
It's not a justification, all I'm saying is that the change is useful in certain situations for me, while someone else would prefer to keep it always on, a bind is a time save if the feature is used frequently
just make a macro that checks every frame if theres a darker pixel over ur tee, if it is it presses an unreachable button which will change ur skin to ice
would be cool if ddnet changed freeze skin to x_freeze, on default clients it could be the same as x_ninja but using another cl_skin_download_url could change the freeze skin to something else
The original reason was master servers getting ddosed constantly. So we added them to our list of servers which was bypassing the master server. However now that we have http masters, maybe it's time to renove that?
The original reason was master servers getting ddosed constantly. So we added them to our list of servers which was bypassing the master server. However now that we have http masters, maybe it's time to renove that?
its not "how to disable this shit" but a way of making many people happy since a lot of people said that there are too many snowflakes and some people said that there is not enough snowflakes
the value range that worked, was so small that it did not make sense to keep that feature, because every value out of the working range, did break the UI ins some way. Why do you ask? Was it helpfull for you?
the value range that worked, was so small that it did not make sense to keep that feature, because every value out of the working range, did break the UI ins some way. Why do you ask? Was it helpfull for you?
yeeahh i loved it, for example with ui_scale I could see more servers and friends than usual, and it was more comfortable in general
its a shame that i cant do it anymore
yeeahh i loved it, for example with ui_scale I could see more servers and friends than usual, and it was more comfortable in general
its a shame that i cant do it anymore
yeeahh i loved it, for example with ui_scale I could see more servers and friends than usual, and it was more comfortable in general
its a shame that i cant do it anymore